Excessive Fines

Candidly reform of how the justice system reforms how fines and fees are imposed should not start with are they unconstitutional. But understanding the constitutional analysis is important.

This new article now available via SSRN authored by Beth Colgan will help your understand. Here is its abstract:

A key component is missing from the Eighth Amendment’s excessive fines clause doctrine: who has the burden of proof?  This question — which has been essentially ignored by both federal and state courts — is not just a second order problem.  Rather, the assignment of burdens of proof is essential to the clause’s enforcement, making it harder — or easier — for the government to abuse the revenue generating capacity of economic sanctions in ways that can entrench poverty, particularly in heavily-policed communities of color.

This Article takes on this question by first sorting through a morass within the U.S. Supreme Court’s due process doctrine as it relates to assessing the fundamental fairness of procedural practices, including the assignment of burdens of proof.  After offering a framework that reconciles the doctrine, it applies that frame to the excessive fines context by breaking the “burden of proof” into four component parts: the burden to raise the excessive fines claim, the burden of producing evidence relevant to that claim, the burden of persuading the decisionmaker as to the result, and the standard of proof to be employed in that determination.  While the government and private interests at stake remain constant across these various burdens, disentangling them allows a more exacting inquiry into the risk of an erroneous imposition of excessive fines.  In particular, it allows examination of how lawmakers have crafted related processes and structures—such as the refusal to provide counsel or the vast array of collateral consequences attached to both non-payment and conviction — that make it more likely that abuses of power will occur absent the check on authority burdens of proof can help provide.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s